Jane Kim takes office as California insurance commissioner on January 4 and has said she will examine the Sustainable Insurance Strategy. Here is what the strategy did, what a commissioner can change alone, what needs the Legislature, and what to tell clients who ask whether their rates are about to fall.
Insurance Journal reported on November 16 that California's incoming insurance commissioner, Jane Kim, intends to review the reforms outgoing Commissioner Ricardo Lara used to coax carriers back into the state's homeowners market. Kim won the November 3 election and takes office on January 4, 2027. Lara is term limited.
If you write in California, your clients are going to ask two questions in the next few weeks. Will my rates come down now, and will my carrier leave again. If you write anywhere else, you will still hear about this, because California's homeowners market is the one every carrier and every reporter watches. This post gives you the facts to answer with, and a clear line between what a commissioner can change on her own and what she cannot.
What the Sustainable Insurance Strategy Actually Did
Lara's Sustainable Insurance Strategy was a trade. Insurers were allowed to use catastrophe models and to include reinsurance costs when setting rates, which California had long restricted, and rate reviews were meant to move faster. In exchange, carriers made commitments to write more policies in wildfire distressed areas.
The results Lara's office points to are concrete. Insurance Journal's reporting lists Farmers removing its cap on new policies, Travelers announcing in April that it would expand its homeowners offerings across the state, and Mercury committing to tens of thousands of new policies over several years. Rate increases were approved alongside those commitments. The same reporting notes the state's homeowners market ran an underwriting loss on average over the ten years ending in 2023, which is the backdrop for why carriers were leaving in the first place.
That trade is what Kim says she wants to examine. Her quote to Insurance Journal: the strategy was put forward as a way to appease insurers who continue to threaten to leave the state in order to raise premiums on hard working families in California, and we're going to be examining this program. She also said she wants rate filings and approvals to be more transparent and wants insurers to pay claims promptly.
What Kim Has Said She Wants to Do
Her campaign positions, as reported by KQED, the San Francisco Chronicle, and her own platform, fall into two buckets.
The first bucket is things a commissioner can do with existing authority. Use rate review more aggressively. Build a public database showing how often each insurer denies claims. Push the FAIR Plan to open its meetings, publish quarterly reports on how smoke claims are resolved, and add public representation to its board. Enforce smoke damage claim handling. She has also talked about rules that would stop an insurer from dropping a client's homeowners policy while keeping the auto policy.
The second bucket is the headline idea: a state run disaster insurance pool for wildfire and flood risk, funded through a portion of premiums, operating alongside the private market. Kim has compared it to how New Zealand and parts of Europe handle catastrophe coverage, and she has said it would reduce reliance on the FAIR Plan over time. She has also acknowledged, per CalMatters, that it is a long term goal that needs the Legislature and the governor. The Senate Republican leader has already said that having taxpayers stand behind that risk is a bridge too far.
What Changes on January 4 and What Does Not
Nothing changes for an in-force policy. A policy issued today is governed by the same contract, the same approved rate, and the same cancellation and non-renewal rules on January 5 as it was on January 3.
Rates that have already been approved stay approved. A new commissioner reviews new filings. She does not reopen a rate that was approved last year. Carriers with filings pending in January will be the first to feel a different review posture, which is why the Personal Insurance Federation of California told Insurance Journal that it is inappropriate for any state official to pre-judge an individual insurer rate filing.
The Sustainable Insurance Strategy is built on adopted regulations. Changing an adopted regulation in California requires a formal rulemaking process with public notice and comment. That takes months at a minimum, and anything that pulls back the catastrophe model or reinsurance provisions would be contested by the industry at every step. Review in January does not mean reversal in January.
The disaster insurance pool requires legislation. The earliest any bill could move is the 2027 session, and it would need the governor's signature. Treat it as a proposal, not a plan with a date.
Wildfire moratoriums continue. The one year non-renewal pauses issued under Insurance Code section 675.1 after a declared emergency are statutory, and they run on their own clock regardless of who holds the office. Our November 12 post covers how those work.
What the Industry Is Saying
The American Property Casualty Insurance Association congratulated Kim and then warned, in its statement to Insurance Journal, that protecting the recent progress in the market is critical, and that costly new mandates or regulatory actions that drive up costs or limit coverage options risk reversing this progress and worsening the crisis.
You do not need to take a side on that. You do need to recognize that carriers will read the same headlines your clients read, and some will slow new business in California while they wait to see what the review means. If a client is shopping and finds fewer carriers quoting in the first quarter, that is the more likely near term effect, not a rate cut.
What to Tell Clients
When a client asks whether rates are coming down: tell them that nothing about their current policy changes in January, that approved rates stay in place, and that the new commissioner has said she will review how future filings are handled. Do not predict a decrease. Nobody has proposed one, and the commissioner herself has framed the first step as examining the program.
When a client asks whether their carrier will leave: tell them that the carriers who returned did so under written commitments, that those commitments do not expire with the election, and that any change to the rules behind them would take a public process they would hear about well in advance.
When a client who is on the FAIR Plan asks what this means for them: tell them the FAIR Plan continues as is, that the incoming commissioner has said she wants more transparency from it and better handling of smoke claims, and that the idea of a state disaster pool to replace it over time is a proposal that needs new law.
When a client outside California asks: tell them California is the largest homeowners market in the country, and its decision to let insurers price with catastrophe models and reinsurance costs was a major shift, so regulators in other states watch what happens there. Then bring the conversation back to their own policy and their own state.
What to Do in Your Book This Week
Pull your California homeowners clients with renewals in January through March. Those are the people most likely to call when the January 4 coverage runs. A short note now, saying you are watching the transition and that their renewal is not affected by it, saves you a dozen anxious calls later.
Note which of your carriers have California rate filings pending. The Department of Insurance posts filings publicly. If a carrier you place with has a filing in the queue, you want to know before a client sees a story about it.
Write a two sentence version of the facts above and give it to everyone who answers your phone. The client who hears a consistent answer from the receptionist, the account manager, and you is the client who stays calm.
If you have clients with open wildfire claims, especially smoke claims, keep documentation tight. Claims handling is the area where the incoming commissioner has been most specific about enforcement, and a well documented file is what moves a stalled claim regardless of who is in office.
A new commissioner reviewing her predecessor's signature program is normal. It is also newsworthy enough that your clients will hear about it before they hear from you, unless you get there first. The facts are simple: nothing changes in January, approved rates stand, the big idea needs a law that does not exist yet, and the carriers that came back did so under commitments that are still in force. Say that clearly and you have done your job.
Sources: Insurance Journal, November 16, 2026, Incoming California Commissioner Kim to Review Lara's Insurance Reforms. KQED 2026 voter guide for California Insurance Commissioner. San Francisco Chronicle, Where the California insurance commissioner candidates stand on 5 major issues. CalMatters, November 2026, Jane Kim declares victory in insurance commissioner race. The Center Square via Times of San Diego, November 14, 2026, Insurance commissioner-elect pushes plan for homeowners. California Department of Insurance, Sustainable Insurance Strategy page.